Do Leaders Really Change When We Build on Their Strengths? What the Research Says

 

Most leadership development has a measurement problem. People finish a programme and say they feel more confident. But did anyone around them notice a difference?

A controlled study by Dr Doug MacKie, published in Consulting Psychology Journal: Practice and Research (2014), tackled this question directly. It is worth a look if you invest in developing leaders.

The study in brief

MacKie worked with 37 executives and senior managers at a large not-for-profit organisation. Their coaching followed a structured, manualised, strengths-based protocol. It involved:

  • Six 90-minute coaching sessions over three months.
  • Feedback from a 360-degree leadership report, plus a strengths assessment.
  • Three goals for each leader: one realised strength, one underused strength, and one learned behaviour or weakness.
  • Ratings in each session of how well the leader was using their strengths.

One group was coached first and the other waited, then the groups swapped. Leadership behaviour was measured by the leaders’ managers, peers and direct reports, not just by the leaders themselves.

What changed

Other people noticed. After coaching, raters at all levels of the organisation saw significant increases in transformational leadership. That means inspiring a shared vision, building trust, encouraging innovation and developing others. The effect was more than three times larger than in the waitlist group at the midpoint.

The wider picture improved too. Coached leaders were rated as more effective and more satisfying to work for. Their people were more willing to put in discretionary effort. Coached leaders also showed less avoidant, “laissez-faire” leadership.

The leaders didn’t see it themselves. The gains showed up in other people’s ratings, not in the leaders’ self-ratings. In the first group, self-ratings actually fell over time as leaders’ views moved closer to how others saw them. This is a good reminder of why honest 360 feedback matters.

Sticking to the approach mattered. Leaders and coaches who followed the strengths-based process more closely saw bigger gains in transformational leadership.

Gains kept growing. The first group kept improving in the three months after coaching ended, which suggests the skills were being used in the workplace.

Why the strengths-based approach worked

The protocol did more than hand leaders a list of strengths. It built four things into every session:

  1. Awareness: knowing your strengths and deliberately applying them to real work challenges.
  2. Optimal use: noticing when a strength is overused, for example when confidence tips into arrogance.
  3. Pairing: combining a strength with complementary skills, such as technical expertise with relationship-building.
  4. Alignment: linking strengths to business goals and to what the person finds intrinsically motivating.

Strengths-based development isn’t about ignoring weaknesses or avoiding hard feedback. It is a disciplined, structured approach to building on what a leader already does well.

What this means for your organisation

Three practical takeaways:

  • Structure matters. A consistent, well-defined coaching approach outperformed “coaching as usual” and made results more predictable.
  • Measure it through other people’s eyes. Use multi-rater feedback to see whether behaviour has actually changed, rather than relying on self-report.
  • Start with what’s working. Building on leaders’ strengths lifts engagement and effort in the people they lead.

How this connects to our work

At Strategic People Group, our work is rooted in positive psychology. We use tools that are simple to apply and well researched, with a track record of improving engagement, collaboration, resilience and wellbeing. Strengths are central to our leadership development, from our six-module leadership programme to our personalised leadership pathway.

The study looked at external executive coaching. Research consistently shows internal coaches create better outcomes. Our Leaders Coach course builds coaching capability in your leaders, so that coaching becomes part of how your organisation works day to day. In this two-day programme, leaders learn to:

  • Coach everyone in their team, not just the people who are struggling, and talk about what’s going well as well as what isn’t.
  • Use the LEADERS skills (Listen actively, Establish trust, Ask open questions, Dream of what could be, Empathise, manage the Ratio of positive to negative communications, focus on Strengths).
  • Structure conversations with the COACH model, from clarifying the situation through to removing roadblocks.
  • Give both recognition and difficult feedback well.

We follow up with each participant after a month and provide cue cards and an app to help the skills stick. You can also add 360 reviews or coaching surveys to track progress, in line with the research above.

Interested in building a strengths-based coaching culture in your organisation? Get in touch with us at enquiries@spgroup.nz or 0508 787 284.


Reference: MacKie, D. (2014). The effectiveness of strength-based executive coaching in enhancing full range leadership development: A controlled study. Consulting Psychology Journal: Practice and Research, 66(2), 118–137.